Modernity and Tradition in Italian Art

Modernity and Tradition in Italian Art

Dr. Mary Ann Calo

What happened in Italy after the great ages for which artists are so well known? What were the legacies of classical antiquity, the Renaissance, and the Baroque once their historical moments had passed? These are complicated questions, especially when considered in the context of increasing tendencies to define modernity as a rejection of these time-honored and revered Italian traditions. By the first decades of the twentieth century, European art had undergone a period of profound structural and philosophical change. Many of the radical aesthetic ideas coming out of France and Germany struggled for legitimacy in a country that remained steeped in history and deeply attached to an artistic legacy that had been admired for centuries. Italian modernism took shape in the context of a constant dialogue between the demands of historical continuity and the influx of new ideas from abroad. In this course, we will learn that notions of modernity can’t be defined by universal principles; they evolve according to local conditions. A country such as Italy will not simply mirror emerging concepts but rather reflect them back on itself.
The course will examine the development of modern art with an emphasis on characteristically Italian modern movements, as well as the involvement of Italian artists in the international art scene. Special consideration will be given to the influence of Italy's political and social history on the formation of modern Italian art. It begins in the late 19th century as Italians seek to gain independence from foreign occupiers and unite as a single nation after years of geographical and political fragmentation. We will then consider the notion of modernity in the early 20th century as it was understood in the avant-garde circles of continental Europe, and its relationship to historical Italian artistic traditions. The course concludes with a look at the figurative tradition for which Italy was so admired, and the emergence of multiple strategies to engage the tensions between modernity and tradition in a newly radicalized political and artist landscape.
Topics will include: the Macchiaioli and the Risorgimento; Futurism and the European Avant-Garde; Metaphysical Art, the Return to Order and early Surrealism; Italian artists and the School of Paris; Italian Post-Modernism.

Course Objectives:
To understand the changes—social, political, philosophical, aesthetic—that resulted in what is called modern art
To understand the fundamental characteristics and aims of European modern art
To understand what it meant to be modern in Italy
To understand how Italian modernity relates to larger developments

Class 1
We will begin by looking at paradigm shifts in the visual arts in late 19th century Europe, especially the development of Realism and Impressionism. We will then consider how ideas coming from France in particular shaped emerging ideas of modernity in Italy. These changes will be understood against the backdrop of the Risorgimento—Italy’s unification movement. The artistic group known as the Macchiaioli, regarded by some as Italy’s version of Impressionism, will be examined in detail.
Boime, Albert (1993). The Art of the Macchia and the Risorgimento. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Broude, Norma (1987). The Macchiaioli: Italian Painters of the Nineteenth Century. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.

Class 2
This class will provide an overview of developments in European modernism during the first decades of the 20th century, specifically cubism, expressionism, and abstraction. It will then focus on an “avant-garde” artistic movement associated specifically with Italy: Futurism. We will consider its relationship to work evolving in Europe, especially in France and Germany, its claims to differences from these trends, and the extent to which Futurism shaped subsequent developments, especially in the Soviet Union.
Greene, Vivien, ed. (2014). Italian Futurism, 1909-1944: Reconstructing the Universe. New York: Guggenheim Museum Exhibition Catalog.
Italian Futurism, 1909–1944: Reconstructing the Universe

Class 3
The final class will provide an overview of modern Italian art in the figurative tradition. The work of Modigliani, an Italian artist associated with what became known as the ”School of Paris,” will first be examined as an example of modernity mediated by tradition. We will then move to the emergence of the “Metaphysical School,” a pseudo-realist style associated with Italian painter Giorgio de Chirco, that signaled simultaneously a return to order in modern art and a drift towards the surreal. Chirico’s influence on a group of late 20th century painters will conclude this discussion.
Emily Braun, et al. (2010). Chaos and Classicism: Art in France, Italy, and Germany, 1918–1936. New York: Guggenheim Museum Exhibition Catalog.
Chaos and Classicism: Art in France, Italy, and Germany, 1918–1936 | The Guggenheim Museums and Foundation

Mary Ann Calo, Batza Professor, Emerita, joined the Colgate University faculty in 1991 as a member of the Department of Art and History. During her 25 years at Colgate, Prof. Calo taught courses on modern and contemporary art history, the arts and public policy, and American art. She also served as Chair of the Art and Art History Department, Associate Dean of the Faculty, Director of the Institute for the Creative and Performing Arts, and Director of the Division of Arts and Humanities. Calo spent many years living and working in Italy, initially as a student and then later as a professor, serving several times as a visiting professor of modern art at Syracuse University in Florence. Since retirement, Calo has led academic tours focused on modern art for the Smithsonian (France) and for Colgate alumni groups (Italy).

Buy:
- Unlimited lifetime access
- Download videos to watch offline
- Available on Apple and Android

Rent:
- Unlimited access for 14 days
- Download videos to watch offline
- Available on Apple and Android

Modernity and Tradition in Italian Art